Categories

« Ehud Barak's latest Nakba | Home | Latma bring you the Palestinian peace budget »

Ehud Barak's latest Nakba

May 16, 2011, 5:10 PM
 |  Bookmark and Share  |   
 

 

Syrian invaders.jpgPrime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Ehud Barak have some explaining to do.

On Sunday, Israel was invaded along its border with Syria. More than 100 Syrians successfully infiltrated the country and rioted violently in Majdal Shams for several hours.

The IDF was reportedly surprised by these events. It was more prepared for violent riots along the borders with Lebanon and Gaza. And security forces were deployed more or less effectively in Jerusalem, the Galilee, the Negev, Judea and Samaria on Sunday.


Jerusalem, a focal point of the unrest since Friday, witnessed rioting in several Arab neighborhoods, which reached its peak with an assault on Hadassah Hospital on Mt. Scopus.

But the government and the IDF were surprised by the invasion from Syria.

What can possibly explain this surprise? And what does it tell us about the defense establishment's ability to cope with the swiftly expanding and changing threats facing Israel?

BEFORE WE consider that issue, we need to understand the nature of the new assault now underway.

Sunday's events were fully anticipated. In 1998, at the height of the so-called peace process, Nobel Peace Prize laureate and PLO/Fatah chieftan Yasser Arafat invented a new Palestinian holiday - the Nakba.

That year, for the first time, Arabs in Judea, Samaria and Gaza rioted on May 15 - the secular date of Israel's establishment in 1948. The purpose of Israel's "peace partner's" initiative was to escalate anti-Israel sentiments of Arabs on both sides of the 1949 armistice lines. And indeed, the next year, for the first time, the Nakba - or catastrophe - of Israel's birth on May 15, 1948 was marked by Israel's Arab citizens.

In the years since, the Palestinians and their brethren throughout the Arab world have consistently escalated their May 15 attacks, with anti-Israel mass demonstrations now common fare throughout the Arab world.

In recent months, Hamas and Fatah have been ratcheting up their incitement and calling for their followers to descend on Jerusalem on May 15. Millions worldwide participated in social media campaigns calling for a third Palestinian intifada to begin on May 15.

Regionally, in recent weeks, as Syrian anti-regime protesters have escalated their calls to overthrow the Assad regime, Hezbollah and the Syrian media have been joining the Nakba incitement efforts. In Egypt as well, as the Muslim Brotherhood consolidates its power, the calls for invading Israel and avenging the Nakba have escalated daily.

Politically, the Nakba campaigns couldn't be an easier target for an Israeli information counteroffensive.

The assertion that Israel's establishment was a catastrophe for the Arabs makes clear that the Palestinian leadership has no interest in living at peace with Israel. This goes for both Fatah, which popularized the term, and Hamas, which was happy to adopt it. If Israel's existence is the Palestinian catastrophe, then obviously, every patriotic Palestinian must seek Israel's destruction.

Actually, the Palestinian and pan-Arab embrace of the Nakba myth doesn't merely demonstrate that they aren't interested in peaceful coexistence. It proves that their true aspirations are nothing short of genocidal.

The declared goal of the Arab armies that invaded the infant State of Israel on May 15, 1948 was to throw every Jewish man, woman and child in the country into the sea. By calling the Arab failure to carry out that plan a catastrophe, today's Nakba rioters and mourners are saying they support the genocidal purpose of the 1948 Arab invaders.

And of course, by making the issue Israel's establishment in 1948, the Palestinians and their supporters are showing that the popular myth that they have no problem with Israel existing within the 1949 armistice lines, and seek only the "liberation" of Israel's heartland of Judea, Samaria and Jerusalem is a complete fabrication. Those areas were lands the Arabs successfully conquered and emptied of Jews in 1948. The Arab occupation of these areas only ended in 1967 because they again invaded Israel with the declared purpose of throwing every Jewish man, woman and child in the country into the sea.

In short, the entire notion of the Nakba is proof that the Palestinians specifically and the Arab world as a whole remain dedicated to the destruction of Israel and the genocide of Jewry.

Netanyahu and the rest of Israel's leaders have the duty to point out this glaring, yet totally ignored fact. And yet, they have been silent.

The most Netanyahu could muster in the lead up to Nakba Day was a true but irrelevant mention of the fact that as full citizens of Israel, Israeli Arabs enjoy more freedoms than citizens of any Arab state.

As for the IDF, it's hard to know where to begin describing its failures to understand or prepare for Sunday's events.

Perhaps the oddest aspect of the IDF's treatment of the mass infiltration from Syria was the IDF Spokesman's Unit's response.

First, IDF Spokesman Brig. Gen. Yoav Mordechai blamed the events on Iran. He called the events an "Iranian provocation aimed at creating friction."

Maybe it was, maybe it wasn't. Certainly Iran is always interested in drawing Israeli blood and weakening the country. But Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad didn't order the rioters to cross the border. Syrian President Bashar Assad did.

As for Assad, an unnamed military source told the media that Assad ordered the whole thing in order to divert world attention from the fact that he is butchering his citizens. As the official said: "This is a cynical and transparent act by the Syrian regime to create a crisis on the border with Israel in order to distract public opinion from the very real problems at home. Syria is a police state; this sort of thing could not happen without the support of the regime. It is clear they wanted this to play the Israel card in order to silence their own democratic opposition."

Well said. But this brings us to the next question: If the IDF understands why this happened, why weren't there sufficient forces along the border armed with riot-control gear to block the infiltrators? Not only was the regime's rationale for the attack easily understandable, the IDF could see the rioters coming. They saw the them get on the buses. They saw the buses coming to the border. There were enough forces along the border to stop a similar penetration from Lebanon.

Why weren't there enough to prevent the Syrians from entering Israeli territory? Why weren't there enough soldiers on the ground to prevent them from entering Majdal Shams, vandalizing the village and flying the Syrian flag inside Israel? Moreover, what does its abject failure to deploy adequately tell us about the defense establishment's ability to properly understand regional developments and trends, and prepare the IDF to protect the country in the face of them?

HERE, TWO aspects of Sunday's events must be borne in mind. First, in general, the events of Nakba day are simply an escalation of the suicide protest campaign that has been ongoing since 2001. The most famous suicide protester to date is Rachel Corrie. And the most successful suicide protest to date was last year's Mavi Marmara suicide flotilla.

Suicide protests have two aims. The first is to humiliate the IDF and Israel. If unarmed suicide protesters are able to take control of a military target for any length of time, their achievement will harm the reputation of the IDF. This goal was achieved on Sunday, when Druse villagers in Majdal Shams were allowed to mediate between the Syrian infiltrators and the IDF.

The second aim is to force the IDF to use lethal force against the protesters and so portray the IDF as a criminal army that kills unarmed civilians. This goal was also partially achieved on Sunday along the Syrian and Lebanese borders.

Since the IDF has already faced suicide protests, it is inexcusable that it has not yet managed to put together a coherent doctrine for contending with them. For instance, why weren't there water cannons along the border with Lebanon?

The other aspect of Sunday's Nakba riots worth noting is that they were the first suicide protests to have taken place on a regional scale since the popular rebellion began in Syria, and since Hosni Mubarak was overthrown in Egypt.

IDF sources interviewed on Sunday claimed that since the Syrian border has been quiet since 1973, they didn't expect it to be active on May 15. What this means is that the IDF failed to recognize ahead of time what its officials were able to recognize after the fact. Namely, that the populist upheavals in the Arab world give Assad (and a lot of other Arab leaders who have kept out of the direct fight against Israel in recent years) good reason to attack. And this new impetus to attack should have led the IDF to deploy forces along the border in sufficient numbers to prevent infiltration.

So why was the IDF unprepared?

THE PERSON most responsible for the IDF's poor handling of events on Sunday is Defense Minister Ehud Barak. And his incompetence is not surprising. Barak is a serial bungler. He is the same man who armed the naval commandos who boarded the Mavi Marmara with paintball guns, even though it was known that the Turkish IHH, which organized the pro-Hamas flotilla, had links to terror groups.

In recent months, Barak has been too busy warning about the widely exaggerated diplomatic "tsunami" at the UN in September, when the Palestinians declare their independence for the second time, to notice events in the Middle East in May.

And that leads to the last disconcerting thing about the defense establishment's surprise at Sunday's events. Commentators and military officials alike are claiming that the Nakba day events are likely a dress rehearsal for even larger riots in September. And this may be true. But it is equally likely that they are the beginning of a new campaign that started this week and will escalate in the weeks and months to come. In this vein, of course we should note that a new, expanded Turkish government-organized pro-Hamas flotilla is set to sail next month with thousands of suicide protesters on more than a dozen ships.

This brings us back to Netanyahu and his relationship with Barak. It is hard to explain Netanyahu's failure to condemn the Palestinians and their supporters for mourning the Arabs' failure to annihilate the Jews of Israel in 1948 without placing it in the context of his close relationship with Barak.

There are many explanations for why Netanyahu gives so much weight to Barak's consistently and dangerously incorrect assessments of regional developments. If they serve no other purpose, Sunday's dismal events must cause Netanyahu to finally reconsiderhis attachment to Barak.

Originally published in The Jerusalem Post.

 

 |  Bookmark and Share

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.carolineglick.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/ipractic/managed-mt-dev/mt-tb.cgi/15350

12 Comments

My dear Caroline,

I had hoped that you would have reminded your readers of my heroic retreat from South Lebanon in the middle of the night and the great peace it has brought to Israel.
And of course lets not forget my most brilliant and visionary move to allow Hamas to rearm and regroup even stronger than before after the Gaza war in 2009 to please Washington,a gift of 'peace' to the incoming president for his inauguration.
That really gave us some much needed points with our dear allies.
It is important that we learn to 'not win' as we did with Hizbollah in order to give the Arabs more self confidence and better their self esteem and this makes my close friends in Washington very happy.

I will answer your two questions ;

'why weren't there sufficient forces along the border armed with riot-control gear to block the infiltrators?'

'why weren't there water cannons along the border with Lebanon? '

You should understand by now the importance of keeping our American friends happy at all costs.
It is more pleasing to Washington if we keep our war,our focus on the Jewish settler problem and this is why the riot control gear and water cannons are kept near the settlements instead of the border area's.
As long as we keep our masters happy that is all that is important.
And by the way,Benjamin is a much better boot licker in Washington than I am,but I'm working on it.

warmest regards,
Ehud the proud loser

Netanyahu will never break with Barak. They are like twins and will sink or swim together. I think Caroline Glick is being too cynical here, and not giving Bibi, Ehud and IDF credit here, for exercising incredible restraint and calm in the face of extreme provocation.

Bibi has an important meeting coming up very soon with Obama at the White House, and then will be delivering his Bar Llan two address to the US Congress. This is not a time to be giving Israel's enemies more ammunition to fire at them,by using excessive force on the Palestinians, who are trying to undermine Bibi's sincere and honest intentions, to create a viable Peace Treaty with the Arabs.

Hey Caroline, I propose a new Israeli holiday. How about September 13 for a counter-nakba day, the anniversary of the signing of the Oslo Accords? (I wonder whether it was Friday the thirteenth. That might explain the horror movie and the various sequels since 1993.)

Perhaps Barak and the IDF have more important things to do than worry about silly problems at the borders. They are too busy training for the next expulsion.

I read that the "nabka" day riots were organized through social media such as facebook, which is now a powerful and well-known tool in the Arab world. The government should be monitoring all those sites -- and also protecting us by putting out "dis-information" on those sites. For example, they could have tried to confuse rioters about where or when to storm the border. I sincerely hope Barak and the IDF thought of this before me!!!

The duo of losers " Bibi-Barak " is a pathetic, spineless, brainless, show dancing to the sweet music of Obama. If you remember the movie " Mash " there was sound column saying " suicide is painless ", well this duo Bibi-Barak is just singing that tune and we stupid israelis are just listening and obeying..I wonder why the Likud is still voting for this stupid , clownesque government.But the truth is that those fat guys in the knesset value their leather chair much more than they value their citizens and their country.

Caroline, the excuses are over! time for you to run for Prime Minister. Caroline for Prime minister!

'Bibi's sincere and honest intentions, to create a viable Peace Treaty with the Arabs.'

This statement steeped in ignorance and delusion is the chief reason why the counterfeit peace process has not been given it's much needed and permanent funeral in dumbed down,brainwashed Israel and why Likud is rudderless.

I will remind the fools of Israel of one event not too long ago as to the reality that any viable peace treaty with the Palestinian's is impossible.
Karine A
Israel should have ended the peace farce back then but then no longer sovereign Israel is ruled from Washington and has no rights or ability to plot their own wise course.
And so Israel plots the doomed fake peace course of her destroyers in Washington with hand picked lap dogs of the empire like Netanyahu Barak ,Livni etc.

Please stop the insane delusions of peace with Palestinian's.
Follow the many examples of history and reality.

Imperial Japan had to be soundly defeated before they were broken and cried for peace.
The same goes for Nazi Germany.
The Palestinian/Arab armies will have to be broken into pieces before any real peace comes to Israel.
Israel's STUPID weakness and appeasement for a fake peace has removed all deterrence.
They will have to lay down their jihad and weapons and cry out for peace before Netanyahu accomplishes anything.
he has to defeat them first and this ignoble, spineless coward only encourages jihad against Israel by his weakness.
Netanyahu and Barak only have the courage to go after the only true remaining Zionists in Israel to please their false gods of the Road Map and this is great evil on their part.
Rewarding jihad and punishing obedient to God builders of Zion.

The government cannot be defensive here because you have identified the purpose of the incursions over the fence, to make Israel's defensive use of force tantamount to genocide. This will continue because it works. If the government chooses not to interdict their operations, it will get far worse, until Israel faces "international forces" who will act on behalf of the "poor oppressed Palestinians".

It's obvious now that this is the plan. The back up of course is the Iranian bomb, should Israel be successful in dissuading "international forces".

The window is closing for them as the 2012 election looms and Israel's enemies are then removed from their offices. The news and entertainment media here is gearing up to full campaign mode, once again, for Obama and his friends however so, there will be nothing but a steady streaming, steaming pile of lies and propaganda and indoctrination. It's too bad that the left was able to gain power over the distribution of information which it then exploited to facilitate itself and it's ideology.

It would appear that Israel has the exact same problem.

Caroline,

I found your site at Breitbart.com when he posted your site. I went to it and listened to one of your speeches and was moved by your soulful passion, then subscribed to your postings.

I love Israel and have always had an interest in her history. There are many like myself who are concerned with what is happening and are praying for divine protection of Israel and her people.

Am enjoying your posts. Thanks so much and peace be with you!

1.Those invasions are not RIOTS, they are INVASIONS, WAR ACTIONS and should be treated as they are with an iron fist , not with a water canon.
All our infantry can shoot rubber bullets as a warning. Then the next shot is full metal ammos.
2:All the border fences are military areas and must be restricted to passers-by , photographers and journalists. It is completely INSANE that the photos and videos of such arab invasions are openly broadcasted to the world and are enhancing the boldness of our ENNEMIES.
3: The Isareli Hasbara dept. the Israeli censorship, the Minister of Foreign Affairs, have not yet - after all those years of hateful TV coverage - learnt the slightest lesson on the importance of hateful images broadcasted all over the world. Therefore they have to ( if they can still think of some improvement measures wich I doubt ) order all TV crews, journalists, passers-by , curious to be cleared from sensitive areas.

Peace was never an option!

Resettling the land required warfare both times before because the land was filled with pagan idol worshippers. And this time is no different.

The Lord of hosts has once again returned his people to the land which he promised to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob: to build the waste cities, replant the land, and establish his laws through his Holy Land. All of it, including Judah and Benjamin's portions.

And I will plant them upon their land, and they shall no more be pulled up out of their land which I have given them, saith the Lord thy G-d.

Woe to any man, or nation, which goes against The Shield of Abraham.

An American Citizens Personal "Apology Tour"...

I am a private, unknown, middle class, American citizen. I would like to apologize to the State of Israel and the Jewish people for the President of the United States...Barack Hussein Obama.

I am ashamed of the speech that he gave on this, the 19th day of May, 2011, where he proposed on the world stage that Israel return to pre-1967 national boundary's.

I didn't vote for him, as in my research during the '08 Primary, I determined that he was, at the least, sympathetic to the muslims, and NOT sympathetic to Israel. This was easy to ascertain based on his associations.

I am apologizing that despite the best efforts of those who saw him for what he was, and is, we were not able to convince those who did vote for him, not to.

I am apologizing for the extreme Far Left media in America that makes it appear that my whole country is against Israel. This is far from the truth. The Far Left media represents a minority opinion in America. They just have the loudest voice.

I would also like to apologize to Britain, Honduras, the Green Movement in Iran, and any other nation or truly Democratic movement that has been injured or insulted by the misguided, Far Left, Anti-Capitalist, Anti-Semitic, or racist policies of the President of the United States...Barack Hussein Obama.

I am truly sorry that he represents my country, and I promise to do everything in my power, within the confines of the Constitution of the United States, to remove him from the Presidency at the end of his first term.

I stand with Israel.

Thank You,
Bruce O'H.
USA

Leave a comment

Powered by Ajax Comments

Syndication

© 2012 Caroline Glick